Re: Be objective...

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Cafe Arabica Discussion Forum ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Sultan on February 02, 19102 at 22:34:49:

In Reply to: Be objective... posted by Moe on February 02, 19102 at 03:19:45:

Firstly, I wonder how a person can understant Islam without hadiths. Many
hadiths are tafsirs which explain many verses of the Quran. It would therefore
be wrong to interpret it according to your own way of thinking. Example, why do
muslims pray 5 times daily when 5 salaats are not mentioned in the Quran? And
how would you know how to pray, if you ignored hadiths? How would you know how
to fast properly? The islamic sharia is built on the Quran and Sunnah. If you
wish to be a muslim, you cannot just pick and choose what suits you.

Secondly, I still think the 19 thing is a distraction. To me it seems like a
kabbalistic approach to the Quran which is wrong.

Follow Ups:

Re: Be objective... Moe 04:12:57 2/03/102 (0)

Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:
Add me to your mailing list:
Subject:
Comments: :Firstly, I wonder how a person can understant Islam without hadiths. Many :hadiths are tafsirs which explain many verses of the Quran. It would therefore :be wrong to interpret it according to your own way of thinking. Example, why do :muslims pray 5 times daily when 5 salaats are not mentioned in the Quran? And :how would you know how to pray, if you ignored hadiths? How would you know how :to fast properly? The islamic sharia is built on the Quran and Sunnah. If you :wish to be a muslim, you cannot just pick and choose what suits you. :Secondly, I still think the 19 thing is a distraction. To me it seems like a :kabbalistic approach to the Quran which is wrong.

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Cafe Arabica Discussion Forum ] [ FAQ ]